en.swpat.org is a wiki.   You can edit it.   May contain statements End Software Patents does not endorse.

November 2014: About Microsoft’s patent licence for .NET core

SitemapCountriesWhy abolish?Law proposalsStudiesCase lawPatent office case lawLawsuits


Suing makers of unfounded accusations

From en.swpat.org
Jump to: navigation, search

What this article documents is not a solution.
For information of the risks of putting too much work into these, see duds and non-solutions. See also: Abolition is the only solution.

Being able to easily sue makers of unfounded accusations may make such allegations less profitable and thus less common.

Of course, this requires a lawyer and readiness to go to court. Many software developers have neither and most small- and medium-sized businesses won't find it worthwhile. This mechanism might only become useful if it was quick and free.

Contents

[edit] In the USA: Slander of title

On what is needed:

Allegations of patent infringement can be slander of title if they are false, reasonably calculated to cause harm, and result in special damages. The court found insufficient evidence of malice to create a jury question. “Mere falsity, prior disputes between the parties, and ‘[s]uspicion, surmise and accusation’ are insufficient to raise an inference of malice.”[1]

[edit] Also possible: Abuse of process?

In the ruling of France's Tribunal de Grande Instance de Paris in the case Samsung v. Apple (2011, France), the judge commented that Samsung's litigation:

The Hague Court also mentioned that it could not be excluded that Samsung’s action be considered on the merits as an abuse of the right to initiate legal actions.[2]
Original: Le tribunal de la Haye a également indiqué qu'il ne pouvait pas être exclu que l'action de SAMSUNG soit considérée au fond comme un abus du droit d'ester en justice.[3]

[edit] External links

[edit] References

  1. "This charming lawsuit (Rebecca Tushnet's 43(B)log)". 2 Oct 2007. http://tushnet.blogspot.com/2007/10/this-charming-lawsuit.html. 
  2. http://www.eplawpatentblog.com/2011/December/2011-12-08_TGI_Paris_Samsung_Apple_translation%284%29.pdf
  3. http://www.eplawpatentblog.com/2011/December/2011-12-08_TGI_Paris_Samsung_c_Apple.pdf


This wiki is part of the End Software Patents (ESP) campaign (donate). For more information, see:
>> endsoftwarepatents.org (Main ESP website) <<
>> endsoftwarepatents.org/news (News) <<

This wiki is publicly editable. (See: en.swpat.org:About) It's a pool of information, not a statement of ESP's views or policies, so no permission is required. Add your knowledge! (See: Help:How to make a good contribution)